Godmothers
First-Edition Subscription Boxes
Each month, our booksellers play literary matchmaker: They handpick a standout, just-published book across genres to deliver to your doorstep. The title is a surprise, but we know one thing for certain—our picks will be the books that everyone’s talking about.
Choose from three first-editions clubs:

For readers looking for a mix of exceptional nonfiction, literary fiction, notable debuts, and acclaimed authors.
These are the books that speak to your soul. Our picks so far—including “Emperor of Gladness,” “Mother Mary Comes to Me,” and “Heart the Lover”—become the chart-topping titles that everyone's talking about.
Pick me ...
- If you like: the titles listed above!
- If these books are close to your heart: “Where’d You Go, Bernadette,” “The Correspondent,” “Bread of Angels”

For readers who crave the unconventional.
If your literary taste lives just outside the margins, you’re in the right place. We celebrate the unusual, the unorthodox, and the sometimes uncomfortable truths of life. Expect experimental prose, characters who make questionable decisions, and plots that may wander—or disappear entirely. Strange Company may get weird, but it’s always a companion worth keeping.
Pick me ...
- If you like: your fiction a little odd, a little risky, and deeply human.
- If these books are close to your heart: “Big Swiss,” “Convenience Store Woman,” “The Guest,” “Parasol Against the Axe”

For readers who wish to step outside the boundaries of real life.
For the wanderers, the creep seekers, and lovers of the mythical, the magical, and the weird. A combination of the best new horror and fantasy hand-picked each month.
Pick me ...
- If you like: otherworldly fiction that transports you to whimsical (or horrifying, or whimsically horrifying) places.
- If these books are close to your heart: “Piranesi,” “Katabasis,” “Catherine House”